Why I Do Not Support the Health Care Bill

Sick, Poor? No thanks.

You already know where I’m going— it’s in the title after all. At this time, I do not support the health care bill. Now before I get into the many reasons why I do not support this legislation, let me spell out the following disclaimers.

I am a small business owner. I am not a Republican. I am not a Democrat. I proudly check the NPA (no party affiliation), when I register to vote for one simple reason— I vote along my ideals and conscious; not along some party mantra. As a general rule, I feel that the government continually mismanages money and our current news media fails to account the statements of government officials to any fact check or truth test.

With that introduction out of the way, I can now describe why I believe our government failed us— as we should expect it to. After all, the Founding Fathers did not want us to depend on our government; and for good reason.

Money, Money, Money

First thing, let’s talk money. The government told us that the new bill will significantly bring down insurance premiums. Sadly, this is wrong. At BEST, the new model brings down premiums $100.00/year. And that’s ONLY if you’re in the “small group family market” or “large group single market.” Individual families will see an increase of $2,100.00/year on their plan. The majority of us will pay either the same, or slightly more for coverage (unless you’re a business).

Let’s remember this: The bill that passed was basically written by America’s Health Insurance Plans (AHIP). You know AHIP, right? They’re the national organization representing roughly 1,300 health insurance companies.

You can’t turn on the news or walk down the street today without hearing about recessions and lost income. Unless of course, you’re in the business of health care. Since October 2009, health care stocks have risen almost 30%. Our new health care laws, written by the health care industry, requires us to purchase health care insurance from the companies that pooled together and wrote the law. The health care companies also significantly contribute to most of the people who voted for the law as well.

How does this boil down for the middle class? Under the new bill, a family of four living on $66,000 will be paying more than $5,000.00 for insurance premiums and be responsible for another $5,800.00 in out of pocket expenses. Of course, they’re also paying another $16,000.00 in federal taxes. So before any out of pocket expenses, this family has $4,125.00 per month to cover all of their living expenses. Bottom line: Middle class will be paying approximately 9.5% of their income on mandated insurance that will cover approximately 70% of their medical expenses.

The bill was touted to stop medical bankruptcy. But, with this bill there’s an $11,900.00 max on out of pocket fees (on top of premiums). Let’s remember, even in 2009, 62% of the bankruptcies filed were medical related (and 75% of those people had insurance). There’s nothing this bill provides that will financially help an average family that must endure a serious medical problem.

You know, the Revolution started in Massachusetts

Massachusetts implemented their health care reform in 2007 and it’s very similar to our new Federal plan. A “3 years later” review from the Kaiser Family Foundation found that 3/4 of Massachusetts’ uninsured had obtained insurance— which is great. Of course, 21% of the population went without needed care because they could not afford it. Also, wait times for seeing doctors increased and health care costs rose.

Massachusetts needed to find many ways to handle the increased health care costs. This included terminating coverage for 30,000 immigrants (legal immigrants with green cards who pay taxes), no longer automatically enrolling low-income residents, and adding $100 million in new fees to private companies.

Of course, with recent Federal overhauls, these same legal immigrants are not entitled to Medicaid or other Federal aid. Nothing says “Welcome to America” better than forcing people to pay taxes and fees for services you then prohibit them from using. Of course, I guess it’s easier to pick on a group of taxpayers that aren’t allowed to vote.

With Massachusetts as the model, we’re in for a great ride.

Let’s wrap it up.

I think the item that bothers me most has to be our Federal Government forcing us to buy health insurance from private companies. I understand the states do this for things like auto insurance — but there’s also a big catch. If I don’t own a car, I don’t need car insurance… How do you do the same for health insurance?

As an American in favor of limited government, any law requiring loss of freedom angers me. Our government passed laws, written by the health insurance companies, requiring us to pay those same companies for health insurance. The much promised transparency for this process never saw sunshine, and sadly there is too much rhetoric going by without adequate investigation by our “free” press.

AT&T, Verizon, 3M and many other large companies have already warned shareholders of profit reduction (in billions) from new health care costs. Our new bill is estimated to cost $1 trillion dollars and from what I can see, not only hits us in taxes— but also in out of pocket expenses.

I’ve had health insurance since I started working full time in 1994. I’ve switched jobs (many times) and have started several businesses along the way. I’ve maintained health insurance the entire time.

This law costs me more while providing me with less. Should I choose to buy better insurance to cover the weak areas, I will be taxed an additional 40% for having a “Cadillac” plan.

So let me ask this: How are you benefiting from this new law?



Fred Posner 2010-04-07 Reply

FredPosner.com: Why I Don't Support the Health Care Bill http://bit.ly/9TKnaL

Lucy Ann Lance 2010-04-07 Reply

From a small biz owner in the Ann Arbor area: RT @fredposner Why I Don't Support the Health Care Bill – http://bit.ly/9TKnaL

jack 2010-04-22 Reply

I can get with you on not supporting “this” bill, but it smacks of the problem with anything: everybody thinks they’re entitled to “feel” some way about everything. Truthfully, you don’t know much. Certainly not enough to claim that it will “save no more than $1oo” let alone all the other things you claim “it will do” and “won’t do.” Not one person who “supports” this, like myself, think that it’s the goal (here’s where you can prove yourself hysterical by claiming that this is just a step to socialized medicine). But the arc of politics doesn’t work that way. It cannot deliver us to distinct places in the mosh pit of legalized deception. All that happened was a battle royal took place of responsibility vs. continued irresponsibility (a wonderful state if you are a member of an uber-elite constituency) and the ball was moved one yard in the direction of civic maturity. To nitpick – and no matter how thoroughly you think you investigated, it is still a shot in the dark to “know” anything – is like standing around at a fire and criticize hoses as an ineffective means of delivering water to the top floors. You might be right, but right now you make a gesture that proves your will. You aim what you have and do what you can. Especially considering that Republicans are working hard to convince everyone that there is no fire, the water will kill your grandmother, the truck is socialist. Fact is, anyone who says that it’s not good enough, who yet believes that something must be done is a narcissist. I don’t mean to sling a harsh word just to hurt, I really believe that it’s true and it is the essence of the distance between, for example, the real debates of minutiae of how to have a financially responsible, non-welfare universal health program and the cartoon debate that is FOX vs MSNBC, or killing grandma vs. socialism. Every person who has spent most of their life knowing little about health care institutions etc who suddenly feels authorized to, upon a skim of the situation, cast Solomon-like assertions is in way way way over their head and discounts every person who has poured years into the very same, who took their best politically viable shot at the one time in 50 years that there was a shot. Why don’t you just admit, you don’t have any idea, hope the people who rose to the responsibility were probably good, normal, non-Marxists and wait and see how it pans out. If you’re moved to action then – real action – then we’ll be glad to hear from you when you know more than .001 percent of what your talking about. Right now the only thing you can be for, if you are against the bill, is keeping the stranglehold of the representatives of the uber- elite over the political conversation.

Fred Posner 2010-04-22 Reply


I’m not even sure where to respond… only that the model of this bill is in Massachusetts. I’ve posted the independent (and neither left / right biased) study on it so that people can see… there are major problems there. This was passed too quickly, with no sunshine, and a lot of assumptions. The real-world example shows many of these assumptions to be completely false.

I’m not sure why you believe that I don’t know anything about the subject… and would ask you to explain how you are a better authority. I’ve got my opinion, and have backed it up with research and sources. I’ve researched this quite thoroughly and respect your opinion, but disagree.

I don’t support the bill. I’m doing this based on my own research and opinion. If you think I’m influenced by things such as FOX and MSNBC, I’d encourage you to read this blog and the words I’ve written about the media (and FOX especially).

“Right now the only thing you can be for, if you are against the bill, is keeping the stranglehold of the representatives of the uber- elite over the political conversation.”

Really? I’m for neither… And I’m not sure why you’re in favor of a bill that was passed without public debate, written by the insurance companies, and modeled after a system that is failing.

kunta bear 2010-04-28 Reply

RT @fredposner: Why I Do Not Support the Health Care Bill http://bit.ly/9TKnaL

WW Ben Franklin Do? 2010-04-28 Reply

RT @fredposner: Why I Do Not Support the Health Care Bill http://bit.ly/9TKnaL

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.